Overview
The Subaru Crosstrek is the brand's most affordable compact SUV, starting at $28,415 for the 2026 model year. While buying a used Crosstrek can seem like a smart way to save, the model’s strong value retention means the savings may be less dramatic than expected.
Depreciation Statistics
Five years after its release, a 2021 Crosstrek typically retains about two‑thirds of its original price.
- iSeeCars reports a 33.6% loss in value.
- CarEdge cites a 33.7% loss.
Resale Values
According to Kelley Blue Book (KBB):
- Average resale price: $16,600.
- Average trade‑in value: $12,450.
These figures are averages across all trims; higher‑spec Limited models may command higher prices due to features like an 8.0‑inch touchscreen and leather seats.
Engine Options & Fuel Economy
2021 introduced a larger 2.5‑liter engine (182 hp) for top trims, borrowed from the Forester. Base models kept the 2.0‑liter engine (152 hp).
- 2.0 L engine with CVT: 30 mpg combined (best fuel economy).
- 2.5 L engine with CVT: 29 mpg combined (slightly lower).
- 2.0 L engine with manual: 25 mpg combined (least efficient).
The modest fuel‑economy drop and added power make the 2.5‑liter option attractive for many buyers.
Buying Tips for Used Crosstreks
Not all model years offer the same value:
- 2021–2024 models consistently provide good value.
- 2018–2019 models can suffer reliability concerns and may not be as cost‑effective.
When shopping, consider trim level, mileage, condition, and whether the larger engine aligns with your performance and efficiency needs.
Conclusion
A 2021 Subaru Crosstrek loses roughly one‑third of its value after five years, still leaving a solid resale price. Buyers who prioritize fuel efficiency, power, and feature upgrades should weigh the benefits of the 2.5‑liter engine against the modest fuel penalty, and focus on model years 2021‑2024 for the best overall value.